Bagels and More: The 10 Best Gifts for Bagel Lovers This Holiday Season

Sam Silverman

Updated December 5, 2022

Smiling man in glasses holding a cream-filled bagel outside a New York bakery

Welcome to our bagel-themed holiday gift guide! If you're looking for the perfect gift for the bagel lover in your life, you've come to the right place. In this guide, we've rounded up a selection of our favorite bagel-themed gifts, including everything from gourmet bagels and spreads to bagel-themed kitchen gadgets and accessories. Whether you're shopping for a foodie, a baker, or just someone who loves a good bagel, we've got you covered. So grab a cup of coffee and a bagel, and let's get started on finding the perfect gift for the bagel lover in your life.

#1: Bagels!

What better gift to get a bagel lover than…bagels! Ship real New York bagels anywhere in the country with Bagel of the Month Club.

Use code BAGELFEST10 for 10% off your order

Bagel baking kit with bagel flour, baker’s yeast, poppy seeds, sesame seeds, everything crunch, and malt packets on a green background

#2: Baz Bagel Baking Kit

Few things tastes better than food you’ve made yourself. Create a true taste of authentic NYC bagels in your home with a bagel baking kit from this charming Soho shop:

Cards Against Humanity Everything Box game box featuring an everything bagel design

#3: Cards Against Humanity: Everything Box

Get the famous card game’s Everything Bagel Expansion pack. Sure to spice up any holiday game night with family and friends!

#4: B is for Bagel Book

From asiago to za’atar, and everything in between, B is for Bagel teaches the whole alphabet, while introducing children to traditional and innovative bagel flavors.

Bagel-shaped wooden handle attached to a white kitchen knife

#5: bagel Knife Spreader

What better way to spread delicious cream cheese on your bagel than with this cute bagel-handled stainless steel knife! Perfect accent to any bagel breakfast or brunch.

#6: Everything Bagel Hot Sauce

It’s everything you love about everything bagel seasoning, in a hot sauce!

Blow Your Mind Bakery cookie bagels gift set with a cookie, gummy candy, cream dip, branded mug, and rhinestone tote bag.

#7: Cookie Bagels Gift Bag

Inspired by the classic New York bagel sandwich, Blow Your Mind Bakery makes a gift pack that features cookie “bagels”, a tub of "cream cheese" frosting, and a pack of "lox" candy fish! The perfect sweet treat.

#8: Commissioned Bagel Portrait

Artist Anna Sanders makes exquisite custom bagel paintings. Inquire today to get yours!

Cookbook titled “Bagels, Schmears, and a Nice Piece of Fish” beside a stack of assorted bagels on a wooden board.

#9: Bagels, Schmears, and a Nice Piece of Fish

A delightful bagel cookbook makes it easy to bake fresh bagels and bagel sandwiches in the comfort of you own home!

#10: NYC Bagel Tour

Join us on a journey through the bustling streets of New York City, sampling some of the best bagels the city has to offer. Our experienced guides will lead you to hidden gems and beloved local spots, giving you the inside scoop on the history and culture of the bagel in New York City.

A gift voucher grants the recipient access to a guided tour at a time convenient for them.

Still Craving bagels?

Head over to our BagelFest shop to browse more merch and offerings.

Collage of three people wearing Brooklyn BagelFest apparel and branded hats, including a woman in a bucket hat, a woman in a black cap and yellow sweater, and a man in glasses outdoors.